Welcome to Pauls Live from New York Pizza Fortuna
Pauls Live from New York Pizza Fortuna, located in Fortuna, CA, offers a dining experience that embodies the essence of East Coast pizza. Customers rave about the flavorful selections, from the crisp Margherita to the sweet and balanced Red Dragon pizza. The establishment prides itself on exceptional service and a warm, inviting atmosphere, making it a favorite for locals and visitors alike. With an array of vegetarian options and impressive lunch specials, this pizzeria ensures there's something for everyone. Whether you're enjoying freshly made slices or deep-fried ravioli, you’re in for a memorable meal that leaves you longing for more.
Pauls Live from New York Pizza Fortuna: Reviews & Ratings
Great place! My son lives locally and said by far, this location is the best of the bunch from Eureka and surrounding area. Food was flavorful, service was fantastic! We were visiting from Nevada and we had never been here. Would definitely make it a place to go if they were in Northern Nevada!
First time here. We got a Margherita pizza. It was the best Margherita we've ever had. Not greasy or heavy at all. Fresh tomatoes! Definitely recommend!!
The red dragon pizza was excellent. Was not too hot, and had a sweetness that balanced it perfectly. Crust was crisp and chewy. One of the best slices I’ve had. Thank you for an wonderful meal.
Fantastic service every time. Constantly great pizza, East Coast style pizza. Great prices. They have a lunch special too! Whole pizza and pizza by the slice. Lots of incredible Vegetarian options. Great atmosphere. I can’t say enough good things about this place. 10/10
Probably one of the best pizza places I've ever been too pizza is amazing their ranch is the best pasta is great and their deep fried ravioli that I didnt even know existed ANAZING !!!!! 10 OUT OF 10
Best pizza I have ever had. Many varieties, buy by the slice which is huge. Mine had ricotta cheese on it. One of Guy Fiera's choices on Diners and Dives.
Clean, friendly staff and great pizza. One of my favorites. Great lunch special. Try their meaty wings and other menu items. You”ll be back.
The menu here is awesome, so much great food. While we are non stop to go orders we're pouring out the door. You can tell that in Fortuna this is THE SPOT! We had pizza and the crust was crappy and yet not too chewy. Just a well done pie. Highly recommend!
Location
-
101 12th St, Fortuna, CA 95540, United States Hotline: +1 707-725-1123
Welcome to Pauls Live from New York Pizza Fortuna, a hidden gem located at 101 12th St, Fortuna, CA, that promises to take your taste buds on an unforgettable journey. Nestled in the heart of Fortuna, this pizza haven is celebrated not just for its authentic East Coast-style pies but also for its vibrant and inviting atmosphere. Whether you're a local or just passing through, Pauls offers an experience that caters to both pizza aficionados and casual diners alike.
One of the standout highlights of Pauls is their exceptional commitment to quality ingredients, ensuring that every slice bursts with flavor. Linda Siders praises it as the “best of the bunch” among pizza spots in Eureka and its surroundings, emphasizing the flavorful menu and fantastic service provided by the staff. This sentiment is echoed across several reviews, showcasing the restaurant's ability to deliver consistent culinary excellence.
The Margherita pizza, a classic favorite among regulars, is lovingly prepared with fresh tomatoes that enhance its deliciousness, making it an absolute must-try as remarked by first-time visitor Jill. Meanwhile, if you're in the mood for something adventurous, don't miss the “Red Dragon” pizza, which Lee Gibbons describes as a perfectly balanced blend of sweetness and spice, with a crust that’s both crisp and chewy—a heavenly combination!
Pauls Live from New York Pizza Fortuna isn't just about pizza; its menu also caters to a variety of tastes. From their amazing pasta dishes to deep-fried ravioli—an unexpected delight according to Allyson Robinson—they assure satisfaction for everyone, including great vegetarian options. Melinda Hogan sums up the experience succinctly, stating that the service is fantastic and the prices are great, making it an ideal spot for a lunch special or family dinner.
With glowing reviews and a menu full of delectable options, Pauls Live from New York Pizza Fortuna stands out as a premier dining destination. Whether you're embracing a casual meal with friends or treating your family to a flavorful feast, this pizzeria's inviting charm and quality offerings will leave you craving more. A visit here is not just recommended; it's essential for pizza lovers everywhere. Come and savor the sensation of New York-style pizza right in beautiful Fortuna!